# Key Lime Pie Co

> The best prices in the Keys! All natural Key Lime desserts including Key Lime Pie, Key Lime Pie on a stick, dessert bars, sauce - Featured on CNBC's The Profit

- **Category:** Shops & Retail
- **Website:** https://keylimepieco.com/
- **Address:** 511 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040
- **Country:** United States
- **Phone:** (305) 517-6720
- **Email:** stephanie@keylimepieco.com
- **Web shop:** Web shop on Shopify: 10 products, $8–$62.99
- **Ships to:** United States
- **Shipping information:** https://keylimepieco.com/pages/shipping-information-1
- **Returns information:** https://keylimepieco.com/policies/refund-policy
- **Book:** https://keylimepieco.com/products/key-lime-pie-making-class-make-your-own-mini-pie
- **Order:** https://keylimepieco.com/collections/all/Merchandise+Pies
- **Contact page:** https://keylimepieco.com/pages/contact

## About
Make your own mini-pie with our pie making class - Book online Our family recipe has been loved and shared locally for decades. Today we continue the legacy of hand-making our 100-year old recipe fresh daily using all-natural ingredients, real key lime juice, and a handmade graham cracker crust. MAJOR YUMMY!!!! This is a treasure located off of Duval St. I love key lime pies and their's is one of the best I have ever had. Fresh and excellent!

## What they sell
Sells: Pies, Shop Our Online Selection, Merchandise, KLP collection, Classes
Price range: $8–$62.99 (10 products)

- Gluten Free Whole Pie!: $30.88 (in stock) — https://keylimepieco.com/products/gluten-free-sunset-deal
- Mini Key Lime Pie: $8.95 (in stock) — https://keylimepieco.com/products/key-lime-mini-pie
- Key Lime Pie in a Cup: $8.95 (in stock) — https://keylimepieco.com/products/key-lime-pie-in-a-cup
- Sunset Key Deal – 2 Key Lime Pies & 6 Key Lime Bars: $62.99–$63.99 (in stock) — https://keylimepieco.com/products/sunset-key-deal
- Sunrise Deal - 1 Pie and 6 Chocolate Dipped Bars: $45.99–$48.99 (in stock) — https://keylimepieco.com/products/the-keys-deal-one-11-pie-and-one-pack-of-bars
- 12 Key Lime Pie Chocolate Dipped Bars: $46.99–$47.99 (in stock) — https://keylimepieco.com/products/get-limed-deal
- Key Lime Pie: $24.99–$25.99 (in stock) — https://keylimepieco.com/products/copy-of-traditional-whole-pie
- The Gluten Free Mini Pie!: $10.88 (in stock) — https://keylimepieco.com/products/gluten-free-pie
- Candles- 13oz, 7oz, 3.5oz: $8–$16 (in stock) — https://keylimepieco.com/products/chino-twill-trucker-hat
- Key Lime Pie Making Class: Make Your Own Mini-Pie: $45 (in stock) — https://keylimepieco.com/products/key-lime-pie-making-class-make-your-own-mini-pie

Products as published by the shop (read from the shop 2026-11-22; the shop last changed its products 2026-11-22; last change seen here 2026-11-22); prices and stock change.

## Opening hours
- Hours: 9:30 am to 9:30 pm Monday thru Sunday

## Services
- Key Lime Pie Making Class: Make Your Own Mini-Pie
- 12 Key Lime Pie Chocolate Dipped Bars
- We do not ship on the week of major holidays!
- No Saturday deliveries or weekend travel time.

## Prices
- Key Lime Pie Making Class: Make Your Own Mini-Pie: $45
- The highest price is: $ 63.99

## Frequently asked questions

**Order Online**
Order Online Online Priced Items Merchandise Shipping Information

**Why do the pies need 2-day shipping?**
Our pies are frozen like ice cream cake! This means that they will melt if not shipped correctly. To make sure they don't melt, we must ship products insulted with dry ice in 2-day to next day shipping.

**I don't live near Key West, can I still order a pie?**
Yes! We ship all over the continental US and offer two-day as well as next-day shipping.

**How many people can one pie serve?**
Our pies can usually make about eight slices, enough to share or enjoy all by yourself!

**Do the pies need to be frozen?**
To keep them fresh and in their shape, you should definitely freeze your pie. They don't take long to thaw once out of the freezer, but once you're finished, make sure to place what you have left in the freezer to enjoy for later!

**Are the pies allergy-friendly?**
Our pies are free from nuts but do include milk, and wheat.

**Share**
Link Close share Copy link

**Availability**
0 selected Reset Availability In stock (8) In stock (8 products) Out of stock (1) Out of stock (1 product)

**Price**
The highest price is $ 63.99 Reset $ From $ To

**Filter and sort Filter**
Filter and sort Filter 8 products Availability Availability In stock (8) In stock (8 products) Out of stock (1) Out of stock (1 products) Clear Apply Price Price The highest price is $ 63.99 $ From $ To Clear Apply Sort by: Featured Most relevant Best selling Alphabetically, A-Z Alphabetically, Z-A Price, low to high Price, high to low Date, old to new Date, new to old Remove all Apply

## Features
- Online booking
- Gluten-free options

## Languages
- English

## Social profiles
- Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/keylimepieco/
- Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/keylimepieco/?hl=en

---
Source: AI Find Me directory (https://aifindme.com/b/key-lime-pie-co). Facts were read from https://keylimepieco.com/ and last checked 2026-11-22; every listing is re-checked about every 7 days. Unclaimed listing. Not yet verified by the business owner.
JSON version: https://aifindme.com/b/key-lime-pie-co.json (it says where each fact comes from)
