# Keystone Cheese

> Female-founded Bethlehem, PA company selling handcrafted Wisconsin cheese, gift boxes, group gifts and fundraisers, shipped nationwide.

- **Category:** Shops & Retail
- **Website:** https://www.keystonecheese.com/
- **Address:** 3232 Keystone Street, 18020 Bethlehem, PA, United States
- **Country:** United States
- **Phone:** +1-484-353-6881
- **Email:** info@keystonefarmscheese.com
- **Founded:** 2014
- **Web shop:** Web shop on Shopify: 203 products, $4–$100
- **Ships to:** United States
- **Free shipping from:** $70
- **Shipping information:** https://www.keystonecheese.com/pages/shipping
- **Returns information:** https://www.keystonecheese.com/policies/refund-policy
- **Pricing:** https://www.keystonecheese.com/pages/shipping
- **Contact page:** https://www.keystonecheese.com/pages/contact

## About
Female founded in 2014, we bring handcrafted cheese from small Wisconsin creameries to Pennsylvania and to cheese lovers nationwide. Formerly Keystone Farms Cheese. Same owner, same team, same Wisconsin cheese, just a shorter name. Owner Nikole spent years traveling between Pennsylvania and Wisconsin to visit her father, a dairy farmer in New Glarus, and her grandmother. She always brought cheese home for family and friends, and she soon realized the taste, quality and unique flavors of Wisconsin cheese weren't available back home in Bethlehem, PA.

## What they sell
Sells: Cheese, Accompaniments, Earthy, Cheddar, Plain, NEW NEW NEW, Herby, Cheese Gift Boxes, Fall Flavors, Fruity, Jams, Crackers, Natural Foods, Cured Meats, Hot & Spicy, Jack, Merchandise, Olives, Aged Cheese, Goat Cheese, Dried Fruits, Blue, Cheese Curds, Mozzarella, BellaVitano, Cheese Spreads, Gouda, Havarti, Pickles, Asiago
Price range: $4–$100 (203 products, 12 shown here)

- DiBruno Brothers Olive Oil Crostini: $7 (in stock) — https://www.keystonecheese.com/products/dibruno-brothers-olive-oil-crostini
- Thanksgiving Board Kit: $59 (in stock) — https://www.keystonecheese.com/products/thanksgiving-board-kit
- The Dare: Extreme Spicy Cheese Gift Box: $62–$73 (in stock) — https://www.keystonecheese.com/products/the-dare
- Holiday Harvest Gift Box: $43–$54 (in stock) — https://www.keystonecheese.com/products/holiday-harvest-gift-box
- The Aged Collection: 18 Year Cheddar Gift Box: $78–$92 (in stock) — https://www.keystonecheese.com/products/the-aged-collection
- Fruit & Cheddar Trio: Sweet Cheese Gift Box: $46–$57 (in stock) — https://www.keystonecheese.com/products/berry-a-peeling
- Cinnamon Apple Cheddar & Asiago Gift Box: $40–$51 (in stock) — https://www.keystonecheese.com/products/box-1
- Turn Up the Heat: Spicy Cheese Gift Box: $46–$57 (in stock) — https://www.keystonecheese.com/products/some-like-it-hot
- Cheddar, Curds & Salami Snack Box: $45–$59 (in stock) — https://www.keystonecheese.com/products/box-2
- Wisconsin Welcome: Cheese & Charcuterie Gift Box: $49–$63 (in stock) — https://www.keystonecheese.com/products/lookin-sharp
- Maytag Bleu Cheese Spread: $16 (in stock) — https://www.keystonecheese.com/products/maytag-blue-cheese-spread
- 18 Year Aged Cheddar: $38–$42 (in stock) — https://www.keystonecheese.com/products/18-year-aged-cheddar

Products as published by the shop (read from the shop 2026-11-22; the shop last changed its products 2026-11-22; last change seen here 2026-11-22); prices and stock change.

## Opening hours
- Mon-Thurs 10-5pm
- Fri. 10-3pm

## Services
- 12 Year Aged Cheddar
- 15 Year Aged Cheddar
- 18 Year Aged Cheddar
- 2 Year Aged White Cheddar
- 5 Year Aged Cheddar
- 7 Year Aged White Cheddar
- A2 Protein Farm Cheddar Cheese
- A2 Protein Garlic & Dill Cheddar Cheese
- A2 Protein Mozzarella
- Aged Swiss
- All Natural String Cheese & Turkey Bacon (Baconwich)
- Asiago
- Asiago w/ Rosemary
- Baby Swiss
- Bacon Cheddar
- BellaVitano Espresso
- BellaVitano Lemon Dill
- BellaVitano Merlot
- BellaVitano Pumpkin Spice
- BellaVitano Tomato Basil
- Black Truffle Goat
- Blueberry Infused Cheddar
- Brick
- Brie Wheel
- Buffalo Cheddar

## Prices
- Subtotal: $0.00
- BellaVitano Pumpkin Spice: $10.00
- LaClare Pumpkin Goat Cheese: $8.00
- from: $10.00
- FREE UPS Ground on orders: $70+
- No reviews: $59.00
- Holiday Harvest Gift Box: from $43.00
- The Whole Sha-BANG: from $75.00
- Keystone Cheese E-Gift Card: from $10.00
- Cheese Cutting Board with Slicer: $65.00
- Medium Cutting Board: $55.00
- Small Cutting Board: $30.00
- Cheese Knife: $16.00
- Mugs: $18.00
- 'Fold in the Cheese' Tee: from $20.00
- 'That's What Cheese Said' Tee: from $20.00
- Aprons: $24.00
- Gift Box Add-on: from $3.00
- Regular price: $14.00
- Sale price: from $13.00
- Aged Swiss: from $13.00
- Baby Swiss: from $15.00
- BellaVitano Espresso: $10.00
- BellaVitano Merlot: $10.00
- BellaVitano Tomato Basil: $10.00
- Caraway Cheddar: from $10.00
- Cheese Curds - Maple Bacon: $11.00
- Cheesewich: $5.00

## Frequently asked questions

**Cheese**
Popular Categories Top Sellers Aged Cheese Hot & Spicy Fall Flavors Mixed Milk Cheese Reduced Fat Products at Festivals Shop By Flavor Earthy Fruity Herby Plain Pungent Sharp Smokey Sweet Truffle Shop By Cheese Type Asiago BellaVitano Blue Brick Cheddar Cheese Curds Cheese Spreads Cheesewiches Farmers Cheese Feta Goat Cheese Gouda Havarti Jack Limburger Mozzarella Parmesan Provolone String Cheese & Sticks Swiss

**Accompaniments**
Balsamic Crackers Cured Meats Dried Fruits Honey Jams Oils Olives Popcorn Pickles

**Merchandise**
Aprons Christmas Ornaments Cutting Boards Knives T-Shirts

**Gifts**
Gift Boxes Gift Cards Ship to Multiple Recipients

**About Us**
Story Fundraising Cheese Blog The Recipe Box Cheeseboard 101 Shipping FAQs

**What is your policy on donation requests?**
YES, always! Please visit our 'Donations' page to make a request!

**What's the shelf life of your products?**
The shelf life on all of our products vary greatly depending on what type of cheeses you have purchased. A good rule of thumb, the younger the cheese, the shorter the self life.Soft cheeses should be eaten more quickly than aged cheeses - a good general rule of thumb is that soft cheese should be eaten within 2 weeks of receipt. The more the cheese is aged the longer it lasts.The firmer the cheese is, and the less moisture it has, the longer it will keep. You can keep aged cheeses for a REALLY long time... (6 months or more). They might develop surface mold on the cut surface, but they're stil

**Can I eat cheese if I am lactose intolerant?**
Many cheeses, particularly aged cheeses such as Cheddar and Swiss, contain little or no lactose. For this reason, cheese is an important source of calcium and many other nutrients found in milk for people who have difficulty digesting lactose or milk's sugar. (For more nutritional information visitwww.nationaldairycouncil.org)

**Is Keystone Cheese rBST free, hormone, antibiotic and gluten-free free?**
Yes, the milk used in Keystone Cheese is rBST free, hormone, antibiotic and gluten free!Recombinant bovine somatotropin (rBST), also called rBGH, is a growth hormone used to increase milk production in cows. According to a 2002 survey by the Department of Agriculture, it is used in 22 percent of the nation's dairy cows. Use of the hormone, which has been sold in the United States since 1994, is controversial because it can cause health problems in cows. Currently there is no test that can distinguish between milk from rBST treated and untreated cows; however, many health conscious consumers pr

**Is it true that cheese is good for my teeth?**
Consuming cheese immediately after meals or as a between-meal snack helps reduce the risk of tooth decay. In particular - Aged Cheddar, Swiss, Blue, Monterey Jack, Brie, Gouda and processed American Cheese have been shown to help prevent tooth decay. Calcium, phosphorus and other components in cheese may contribute to this beneficial effect. For more nutritional information visitwww.usdairy.com.

**What is the crunch or hard crystals found in aged cheese?**
This is Calcium Lactate which is often found in aged cheeses. Small crystals of it precipitate out when lactic acid is converted into a less soluble form by the bacteria active during the ripening process.

**Which cheeses are hard and which are soft?**
Hard: Asiago, Bellavitano, ParmesanSemi-Hard: Baby Swiss, Cheddar, Edam, Gouda, Romano, Swiss, MontamoreSemi-Soft: Brick, Colby, Colby Jack, Monterey Jack, Pepper Jack, Habanero Jack, Farmers, Fontina, Havarti, Limburger, MunsterSoft & Fresh: Feta, Juusto, Goat Pasta Filata: Mozzarella, Provolone, StringProcesses/Cold Packed: Cheese Spreads, Smoked Cheddar Smoke Swiss, Dairy Fudge, Processed Bacon, Processed Salami, Sliced AmericanBlue: Blue

**How does the cheese stay cold during transit?**
This all depends on the time of year, weather and your location. STANDARD INSULATIONThis is complimentary and will include ice packs. During winter months and shorter transit times, less insulation is needed especially in the north. Our standard insulation includes packaging that stays cool for 24 or 48 hours.INSULTED COOLER BOX - additional costDuring the summer months and for transit to southern states and the west coast, we require you purchase a insulated cooler. There is an additional cost for the cooler, ice packs are complimentary. These are found at the end of every shopping page. Purc

**My cheese arrived warm, what should I do with it?**
Refrigerate the cheese upon arrival. Although cheese may be warm, it can still be consumed.A great way to really know if the cheese got too warm is to put the cheese in the refrigerator and wait to see if it puffs up. If the packaging gets puffy, at one point the temperature got too high.

**What do I do if my items are damaged or incorrect?**
If your items arrived damaged or incorrect, please reach out to us at info@keystonefarmscheese.com or at 484-353-6881.

**What is your Return Policy?**
100% Satisfaction Guaranteed: We stand by every product we sell and every gift we deliver. If, for any reason, you or your gift recipients are not completely satisfied with a Keystone Cheese item, simply call or email within 48 hours for a replacement, refund or credit - whichever you prefer. We promise to handle your request promptly and courteously. For more information you can go to our Refund Policy pageWe guarantee it.

**How much milk does it take to make a pound of cheese?**
It takes about 10 pounds (5 quarts) of milk to make 1 pound of whole milk cheese. For our 75 pound mammoth wheel, it would take 750 pounds, or 87 gallons, and take approximately 15 cows to produce enough milk.

**What are starter or "friendly" cultures?**
Also called starter cultures, friendly cultures are added to milk at the start of the cheesemaking process. The cultures change the lactose or milk sugar (the only carbohydrate in milk) into lactic acid. This equalizes the pH so the milk protein will form curds when the rennet is added. The cultures used by the cheesemaker are a closely guarded secret as they contribute to the distinct qualitites of each cheese.

**What is Rennet?**
Rennet is a coagulating enzyme used to curdle milk. causing clumps (curds) to form and separate from the liquid (whey). Rennet is added after the cultures and is also integral to the final flavor of the cheese. Until recently, rennet was derived from the stomach lining of a calf, goat or lamb. Now, many cheesemakers use vegetable rennet (derived from plants) or microbial rennet. In addition to being less expensive than traditional animal rennet, vegetable and microbial rennet allow cheesemakers to craft cheeses suitable for vegetarians.

**What is Annatto?**
Annato is a natural food coloring derived from the ground seed pods of the annato tree, native to Centeral and South America. Cheese is naturally the color of the milk, from which it is made. Some cheeses have a yellow or lightly orange hue use caused by the vitamin A that cows ingest from grazing out in lush pastures. During cold winter months, cows come in from the pastures and are fed silage (forage plants that are stored in a silo) and the cheeses that result from this milk are white. This variation persuades some cheesemakers to color their cheeses so they will look uniformly nutritious.

## Features
- Free shipping
- Family owned
- Gift cards
- Delivery
- Gluten-free options
- Vegetarian options

## Payment methods
- Gift card

## Languages
- English

## Social profiles
- Instagram: https://instagram.com/keystonecheesepa
- Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/keystonefarmscheese
- Pinterest: https://www.pinterest.com/keystonefarmscheese

---
Source: AI Find Me directory (https://aifindme.com/b/keystone-cheese). Facts were read from https://www.keystonecheese.com/ and last checked 2026-11-22; every listing is re-checked about every 7 days. Unclaimed listing. Not yet verified by the business owner.
JSON version: https://aifindme.com/b/keystone-cheese.json (it says where each fact comes from)
