The Cheese Guy in New York City
Shops & Retail in New York City · Web shop on Shopify · Unclaimed · Not verified by owner · facts last checked 17 November 2026 · read from thecheeseguy.com.
Facts
| Name | The Cheese Guy |
|---|---|
| Category | Shops & Retail |
| Summary | Find the perfect cheese for any occasion with The Cheese Guy. We offer a delectable selection of premium, artisanal, vegetarian, handcrafted cheeses that are full-flavored and kosher. From local NY beer-infused cheddars to spicy hot cheeses, our selection includes raw milk, organic sharp cheddars, a |
| Website | thecheeseguy.com |
| Address | 1001 New York City, Yonkers, United States |
| City | New York City |
| Region | Yonkers |
| Postal code | 1001 |
| Country | United States |
| Map location | Map |
| Phone | +7186985154 |
| ar@oldworldmarketplace.com | |
| Contact page | https://thecheeseguy.com/pages/contact |
| Booking link | https://thecheeseguy.com/pages/events |
| Order link | https://thecheeseguy.com/collections/all |
| Founded | 2008 |
| Payment methods | Visa, Mastercard, American Express, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Shop Pay |
| Languages | English |
| Web shop | Web shop on Shopify: 133 products, $5–$550 |
| Currency | USD |
| What they sell | Current Online Selection, Super Kosher (Chalav Yisrael) Cheeses, Kosher for Passover, Cheese Accompaniments Collection, Imported Cheese Collection, Aged or Hard Cheese Collection, New Products, Heartland/ New Engalnd Collections (CRC Kosher), Hard Cheeses: Asiago, Parm and Romano, Goat and Sheep Milk Cheese Collection, Lactose-Free Cheese Collection, Specialty Crackers, Biscotti & Breadsticks, Grated, Shredded and Shaved Cheeses, Bulk (Food Service) Size, Raw Milk Cheese Collection, Essentials Collection, Sustainable (Ugly 😜) Cheese Boxes, Platters and Baskets, Gift Card, Merch |
| Number of products | 133 |
| Product prices | $5–$550 |
| Last product update | 17 November 2026 |
| Ships to | United States, Canada |
| Social profiles | Facebook · Instagram |
| Logo | https://tapita.io/pb/pub/media/spb/usr/8739/wysiwyg/58830192721/cheeeses_1__1.png |
| Image | http://thecheeseguy.com/cdn/shop/files/The_Cheese_Guy.jpg?v=1733929067 |
About
Monthly subscriptions on individual cheeses are now available. Select the subscription from the product page and head to checkout! Daring and delicious, small-batch, kosher, all-natural cheeses that are not only delicious but also align with your values. "In my cheese universe, innovation and tradition intertwine. Unlike many counterparts that rely on animal rennet, I pledge to use only plant-based or microbial non-animal enzymes. Over the past two decades, I've poured my heart into perfecting recipes and sourcing top-tier ingredients, resulting in mouthwatering artisanal cheeses that cater to cheese lovers of all dietary preferences – from the strictly kosher to the unabashed omnivore."
Prices
| Cheddar, Smoked | $14.00 |
|---|---|
| Gouda, Truffle | $14.00 |
| Feta, Domestic | $9.00 |
| Gouda, Truffle Bulk Loaf | $125.00 |
| Swiss, Lacey Baby Bulk Loaf | $120.00 |
| Pecorino Romano, Quarter Wheel | $225.00 |
| Marble Cheddar Loaf, OU-CY-P | $90.00 |
| Aged Asiago Loaf, OU-CY-P | $110.00 |
| Gouda Loaf, OU-CY-P | $90.00 |
| Pepper Jack Loaf, OU-CY | $90.00 |
| Cheddar, Mild Loaf | $120.00 |
| Cheddar, Chipotle Loaf | $125.00 |
| Medium Cheddar Loaf, OU-CY-P | $90.00 |
| Aged Havarti Loaf, OU-CY-P | $90.00 |
| Pecorino Romano | $18.00 |
| Provolone Smoked | $16.00 |
| Chagall | $16.00 |
| Cheddar, Vermont Raw Milk | $15.00 |
| Fromage De Paulette | $17.00 |
| Blue Cheese | $15.00 |
| Brie, French | $17.00 |
| Havarti, Aged | $12.00 |
| Cheddar, Medium Yellow | $10.00 |
| Cheddar, Cranberry | $15.00 |
| Almond Italian Biscotti | $6.00 |
| Balsamic Glaze Bottle | $13.00 |
| Blue Cheese, Crumbled | $6.00 |
| Blue, "Lazio Blue" Cheese | $20.00 |
| Breadsticks, Classic | $5.00 |
| Brie, French with Truffle | $99.00 |
Frequently asked questions
- Search
- Search Clear
- Availability
- In stock Out of stock
- Price
- $ From - $ To
- Are your cheeses Kosher certified?
- Our cheeses are proudly OU Kosher Certified.
- Are all of your cheeses vegetarian?
- Yes, all of our cheeses are crafted with no added hormones, animal rennet, lipase, or lard.
- Are your cheeses Lactose-Free?
- Not all of our cheeses are lactose-free, however we do have a lactose-free selection. Check it out here: Lactose-Free Cheese Collection.
- SHIPPING POLICY
- Every package is shipped in an insulated Styrofoam cooler. If you are placing an order during the “warm” season, AND/OR the destination is in a “warmer” climate, we recommend that you select any of the available expedited shipping options (not UPS Ground). If you choose to proceed without expedited shipping to your order with the conditions above, The Cheese Guy can not be held liable for poor quality product arriving to you.We are not responsible for non-delivery if any of the following instances occur:-If we are provided an incomplete or incorrect address-Missing building number, apartment n
- Do you ship internationally?
- Currently, we deliver our delicious cheese selections to all states within the continental US, and we're thrilled to announce that we're now also shipping to Canada!
- How long will it take to receive my order?
- To keep your cheese fresh, we aim to deliver orders within 2 business days after processing. Our shipping schedule depends on the service you choose:Order Cutoff Time: 12 PM (EST) for same-day processingOrders placed after the cutoff time will be processed on the next business day. (Monday - Friday, Except Holidays)UPS Ground: Ships Monday-Wednesday.UPS 2nd Day Air: Ships Monday-Wednesday. Thursday orders can be processed on the same day only if you select the UPS 2nd Day Air Saturday Delivery option at checkout. UPS Next Day Air & Saver: Ships Monday-Thursday.
- What are your shipping options?
- Our cheeses need to be refrigerated by you, within 2 days of the product being shipped, in order to maintain peak flavor and texture. That's why we offer a variety of expedited shipping options through UPS Ground® (for locations near the warehouse—Bay Shore, New York), UPS 2nd Day Air®, UPS Next Day Air®, and UPS Next Day Air Saver®. The specific cost will depend on your chosen service and location, but you'll see the exact amount during checkout.
- Can I have a replacement for a spoil item?
- We understand cheese is meant to be enjoyed fresh and delicious. If our cheese didn't arrive in perfect condition, we're truly sorry for the inconvenience. Here's how we can make it right:Please reach out to us within 14 days of receiving your order at info@thecheeseguy.com. Let us know your order number, and a description of the issue relating to spoiled product (e.g cheese arrived moldy). We’ll work with you to find the best solution.
- What payment methods are accepted?
- We accept major credit cards such as Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover, Diners Club and popular digital wallets: Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Meta Pay,and Paypal.
- Where can I find a cheese shop near me?
- Our cheese shops are conveniently located nationwide. You can go ahead and check the available stores near you from our Store Locator or email us at info@thecheeseguy.com for more queries.
- Can I change or cancel my order once it has been placed?
- We prioritize your order's prompt processing and shipment because it's important to us.If you need to make changes, please contact us as soon as possible via email at info@thecheeseguy.com or by calling 718-698-5154.We'll do our best to intercept your order before shipment if it hasn't been processed yet. However, once your order is placed, we unfortunately cannot add, remove items, or make any other modifications.For Processed Orders:If your order has already been processed, unfortunately, we cannot accept returns due to the perishable nature of our cheese. However, we recommend checking your
Features
- Vegetarian options
- Family owned
- Kosher
- Gift cards
- Family friendly
- Delivery
What they sell
Web shop on Shopify: 133 products, $5–$550. Sells: Current Online Selection, Super Kosher (Chalav Yisrael) Cheeses, Kosher for Passover, Cheese Accompaniments Collection, Imported Cheese Collection, Aged or Hard Cheese Collection, New Products, Heartland/ New Engalnd Collections (CRC Kosher), Hard Cheeses: Asiago, Parm and Romano, Goat and Sheep Milk Cheese Collection, Lactose-Free Cheese Collection, Specialty Crackers, Biscotti & Breadsticks, Grated, Shredded and Shaved Cheeses, Bulk (Food Service) Size, Raw Milk Cheese Collection, Essentials Collection, Sustainable (Ugly 😜) Cheese Boxes, Platters and Baskets, Gift Card, Merch.
- Goat Cheddar, Aged 18 Months: $15 (in stock) · image
- Peach and Amaretto Preserve: $10 (in stock) · image
- Cheddar, Sharp (Essentials): $7 (in stock) · image
- Gouda, Smoky CY Slices (Heartland): $8 (in stock) · image
- Havarti, Dill CY Slices (Heartland): $8 (in stock) · image
- Havarti, CY Slices (Heartland): $8 (in stock) · image
- Gouda, CY Slices (Heartland): $8 (in stock) · image
- Cheddar, Medium Slices (Heartland): $8 (in stock) · image
- Balsamic Vinegar 5L Bottle: $48 (in stock) · image
- Balsamic Glaze Bottle: $13 (in stock) · image
- Emmental, Swiss Cheese: $20 (in stock) · image
- Havarti, Essentials: $7 (in stock) · image
Verification
Unclaimed · Not verified by owner. Nobody has claimed this listing yet, so no fact has been confirmed by the business itself. Verification state: unclaimed.
Key facts on this card: 10 of 11; missing: Opening hours. AI-ready (at least 8 of 11 key facts filled in).
Is this your business? Claim this listing (free: prove you control the website, and the badge changes to “Verified by owner”). What claiming means.
Where these facts come from
Read from thecheeseguy.com. Last checked 17 November 2026 (6 days ago); last changed 6 days ago; listed since 17 November 2026. Every listing is re-checked about every 7 days.
| Fact | Found in | Page |
|---|---|---|
| Name | structured data | / |
| Summary | structured data | / |
| About | page text | /pages/about |
| Address | structured data | / |
| City | structured data | / |
| Region | structured data | / |
| Postal code | structured data | / |
| Country | structured data | / |
| Phone | structured data | / |
| structured data | / | |
| Prices | page text | /, /collections/bulk-cheeses-foodservice, /collections/all, /collections/current-online-selection |
| FAQs | page text | /, /pages/contact, /collections/bulk-cheeses-foodservice, /pages/about, /pages/thecheeseguy-frequently-asked-questions, /pages/terms-and-conditions, /pages/events-book-an-event, /collections/all, /collections/current-online-selection |
| Features | page text | /, /pages/contact, /collections/bulk-cheeses-foodservice, /pages/about, /pages/thecheeseguy-frequently-asked-questions, /pages/terms-and-conditions, /pages/events-book-an-event, /collections/all, /collections/current-online-selection |
| Payment methods | page text | /pages/thecheeseguy-frequently-asked-questions, /pages/terms-and-conditions |
| Languages | page metadata | /, /pages/contact, /collections/bulk-cheeses-foodservice, /pages/about, /pages/thecheeseguy-frequently-asked-questions, /pages/terms-and-conditions, /pages/events-book-an-event, /collections/all, /collections/current-online-selection |
| Founded | structured data | / |
| Logo | structured data | / |
| Image | page metadata | / |
| Social profiles | structured data | /, /pages/contact, /collections/bulk-cheeses-foodservice, /pages/about, /pages/thecheeseguy-frequently-asked-questions, /pages/terms-and-conditions, /pages/events-book-an-event, /collections/all, /collections/current-online-selection |
| Booking link | page text | / |
| Order link | page text | /pages/about |
| Contact page | page text | / |
| Category | page text | / |
| Web shop | page metadata | / |
| Shop platform | page metadata | / |
| Currency | shop platform data | /products.json |
| Shop status | shop platform data | /products.json |
| Number of products | shop platform data | /products.json |
| Ships to | shop platform data | /meta.json |
| Last product update | shop platform data | /products.json |
| Product prices | shop platform data | /products.json |
| What they sell | shop platform data | /products.json |
Recent checks
- 6 days ago: Added to the directory
Links
- Markdown fact card · JSON fact card (every fact with its source) · llms.txt · API · products API · documentation, OpenAPI and the MCP server
- Report this listing · Ask for removal
How to use this site as an agent
| This page as Markdown | https://aifindme.com/b/the-cheese-guy.md (or send Accept: text/markdown to this address) |
|---|---|
| This page as JSON | https://aifindme.com/b/the-cheese-guy.json (or Accept: application/json) |
| This page as llms.txt | https://aifindme.com/b/the-cheese-guy/llms.txt |
| This page through the API | https://aifindme.com/api/v1/businesses/the-cheese-guy |
| Start here | https://aifindme.com/agents: what a fact card guarantees, the three ways to query, rules and rate limits, freshness, how to add or correct a business. Long form: https://aifindme.com/for-ai-agents |
| Search API | GET https://aifindme.com/api/v1/businesses?q=…&category=…&city=…&kind=shop&verified=1&open=now · OpenAPI · documentation |
| MCP server | POST https://aifindme.com/mcp (Streamable HTTP, no key): search_businesses, get_business, get_products, list_new_listings, list_categories, list_cities |
| Directory index | https://aifindme.com/llms.txt: every category and city with counts, and the latest listings · https://aifindme.com/llms-full.txt: one compact entry per listing |
| Agent skill | https://aifindme.com/skills/aifindme/SKILL.md: when and how to use this directory and how to cite it (Agent Skills format) |
| Views | Add ?view=ai or ?view=human to any address. Both carry the same facts and links; only the presentation differs. |